Totonno’s
Totonno’s Pizzeria Napoletana is much more than just a pizzeria in Coney Island, Brooklyn: it’s a historic treasure and a cornerstone of New York pizza culture. Founded in 1924 by Antonio “Totonno” Pero, an Italian immigrant who worked at Lombardi’s (America’s first pizzeria), this place represents the authenticity and tradition of coal-fired oven pizza. 🍕
Located on Neptune Avenue, a short distance from the famous Coney Island boardwalk, Totonno’s is a mandatory stop for pizza lovers and anyone wanting to experience a piece of New York history. Its simple atmosphere and legendary pizza, made with the same recipe for nearly a century, make it an unforgettable and genuine experience.
Why Visit Totonno’s?
Visiting Totonno’s means connecting directly with the roots of pizza in New York. It’s a legendary place that combines family history, authentic flavor, and an unwavering dedication to quality. Here, the pizza is baked in a century-old coal oven, giving it that characteristic flavor and texture impossible to replicate. 🔥
Its cultural importance is undeniable: it has been recognized with the prestigious James Beard Foundation America’s Classic award and has survived countless challenges, including Hurricane Sandy and several fires, demonstrating the resilience of the Perrone family, descendants of Totonno. It is a living testament to New York’s culinary tradition.
Totonno’s is also a symbol of perseverance and authenticity. Despite its worldwide fame, it maintains an unpretentious atmosphere, focused solely on offering exceptional pizza. If you want to try one of the city’s most legendary pizzas, this is the place. 💯
How to Get to Totonno’s by Subway?
Main Stations
The main station closest to Totonno’s is Neptune Av, served by the F train. Another nearby option, although it requires a bit more walking, is the large Coney Island–Stillwell Av station, a major transportation hub connecting several lines and offering direct access to Coney Island attractions. 🚇
Subway Lines to Totonno’s
Totonno’s is well-served by the New York City subway. The lines that take you near this destination are:
- F (orange line) – Stop at Neptune Av (closest)
- D, F, N, Q (orange, yellow lines) – Stop at Coney Island–Stillwell Av
How to Get to Totonno’s From:
Manhattan (Midtown / Times Square)
From Midtown Manhattan, you can take the F train (towards Coney Island–Stillwell Av) directly to the Neptune Av station. Alternatively, you can take the D, N, or Q trains to Coney Island–Stillwell Av and walk about 10-15 minutes.
Lower Manhattan (Wall Street / World Trade Center)
From Lower Manhattan, you can easily access the D, F, N, or Q trains heading south (Brooklyn) and follow the directions above, getting off at Neptune Av (F train) or Coney Island–Stillwell Av (D, N, Q trains).
Brooklyn (Downtown / Park Slope)
From areas like Downtown Brooklyn or Park Slope, the F train is the most direct option to Neptune Av. If you are closer to the D, N, or Q lines, you can take them to Coney Island–Stillwell Av.
Queens (Long Island City / Flushing)
From Long Island City, you can take the F train directly to Neptune Av. From Flushing, take the 7 train to 74 St–Broadway and transfer to the F train towards Coney Island.
Harlem
From Harlem, take a train that connects with the southbound D or F trains (Downtown/Brooklyn), such as the A or C train to West 4th St to transfer to the F or D, and continue to Coney Island.
Airports (JFK / LaGuardia / Newark)
From JFK, take the AirTrain to Howard Beach–JFK Airport and transfer to the A train to Jay St–MetroTech, then switch to the F train to Neptune Av. From LaGuardia, take the Q70-SBS bus to Roosevelt Av/74 St and transfer to the F train. From Newark, take NJ Transit to Penn Station (NY) and then the F subway train.
What to Do at Totonno’s?
Totonno’s is a pilgrimage for pizza enthusiasts. The experience goes beyond simply eating; it’s about savoring the history and dedication in every bite. Remember, people come here for the classic pizza, prepared with mastery. 🤌
Enjoy the Legendary Pizza
The main attraction is, undoubtedly, its pizza. Made in a coal oven, it has a thin, slightly charred crust, topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The options are usually simple: Margherita (tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil) or Bianca (no tomato). They are sold as whole pizzas, not by the slice. Prepare for a treat!
Absorb the History
The interior of Totonno’s breathes history. The walls are adorned with old photos, press clippings, and family memorabilia that tell the rich story of the pizzeria. Sitting at its simple tables is like traveling back in time to a New York of another era. 🕰️
Experience the Authenticity
Totonno’s offers an authentic, no-frills experience. The service is straightforward, the atmosphere is familiar, and the focus is entirely on the pizza. Historically, it has been cash only (it’s wise to check before going!), which reinforces its traditional character. 💵
Combine with Coney Island
A visit to Totonno’s is the perfect excuse to explore Coney Island. Before or after your pizza, you can stroll along the famous boardwalk, enjoy the beach, or have fun on the rides at Luna Park. 🎡
Be Patient
Given its renown and limited capacity, you might have to wait for a table, especially on weekends or during peak season. The wait is part of the experience and, according to devotees, it’s worth it. 🙏
Attractions Near Totonno’s
Totonno’s is located in the heart of Coney Island, a neighborhood with a unique personality and full of iconic attractions. Take advantage of your visit to explore the surroundings and immerse yourself in the beachy and nostalgic atmosphere of the area.
Coney Island Boardwalk and Beach
Just a few minutes’ walk from Totonno’s is the legendary Coney Island boardwalk and its wide beach. It’s perfect for a stroll, enjoying the views of the Atlantic Ocean, and breathing in the sea breeze. 🏖️
Luna Park
The famous amusement park Luna Park is very close. With historic roller coasters like the Cyclone and modern attractions, it’s an ideal place to have fun after a good pizza. 🎢
New York Aquarium
Located on the boardwalk, the New York Aquarium offers fascinating marine life exhibits, including sharks, penguins, and sea otters. It’s an excellent option for families. 🐠🐙
Nathan’s Famous
No visit to Coney Island is complete without trying a hot dog at Nathan’s Famous, the original home of the famous July 4th hot dog eating contest. It’s located near the Stillwell Av station. 🌭
MCU Park
If you’re a baseball fan, MCU Park (home of the Brooklyn Cyclones, a minor league affiliate of the Mets) is right next to the boardwalk. Watching a game here is a very local experience. ⚾
Coney Art Walls
During the warmer months, you can visit the Coney Art Walls, an outdoor urban art gallery featuring vibrant murals created by local and international artists. (Subject to seasonal availability). 🎨
Tips for Visiting Totonno’s
Visiting Totonno’s is a special experience, but it requires a bit of planning, especially due to its history of temporary closures and its popularity. Here are some tips to make your pizza pilgrimage perfect.
Best Time of Day to Go
To avoid the biggest crowds, try going on a weekday or right when they open. Weekends, especially in summer, tend to be the busiest times. An early or late meal might help you get a table faster. 🕒
Check Hours and Status
VERY IMPORTANT! Totonno’s has had intermittent closures due to hurricane damage, fires, or the pandemic. Before heading to Coney Island specifically for Totonno’s, call them or check their social media/website to confirm they are open and what their current hours are. 📞🗓️
Bring Cash
Traditionally, Totonno’s has been a cash-only establishment. While this may change, it’s wise to bring enough cash just in case. Check when you call if they currently accept cards. 💵
Be Respectful of Tradition
Appreciate the place for what it is: a historic pizzeria with a simple menu and a focus on quality. Don’t expect an extensive menu or modern luxuries. Enjoy the pizza and the history-filled atmosphere. 🙏
Order a Whole Pizza
Remember that Totonno’s serves whole pizzas, not individual slices. Go hungry or with a group to enjoy it to the fullest. The quality of the ingredients and the coal oven make every pizza special! 😊
